How to Handle Unrealistic Goals Without Burning Out Your Team

Feeling the Pressure of Impossible Expectations?

Are you feeling overwhelmed by impossible targets? Do your goals spark anxiety instead of motivation? If you’re starting to dread work because the expectations placed on you and your team feel unattainable, you’re not alone.

In many organizations—regardless of industry or market maturity—leaders set goals that push teams beyond their limits. Sometimes, it’s because past success came at a high cost, and that sacrifice is then treated as a new baseline. Other times, decision-makers simply want to extract more from the same or fewer resources. The result? Employees are asked to do more with less—less time, less support, and less energy.

Why Unrealistic Goals Are So Common

This pressure often takes the form of stretch goals—objectives designed to exceed past performance challenging the team to go above and beyond. When thoughtfully applied, stretch goals can energize high performers, stimulate growth, and spark innovation. But when these goals are unrealistic, they can do more harm than good. They shift from being challenging to being demoralizing, especially when they’re linked solely to profitability without regard for the human cost.

When Stretch Goals Become Stress Goals

Unrealistic goals are even more dangerous in cultures that don’t allow room for mistakes. In environments where even minor errors lead to punishment, employees often choose to stay silent rather than speak up. Over time, this fear breeds a lack of transparency, and when the inevitable cracks appear, decision-makers are often caught off guard. Mistakes should be seen as learning opportunities—but in high-pressure, zero-tolerance environments, they become a source of fear and cover-up.

The Hidden Costs of Unrealistic Expectations

The consequences of setting unrealistic goals ripple throughout an organization. Morale drops, and teams begin to feel a sense of hopelessness. Colleagues stop collaborating and instead compete, often unethically, simply to meet quotas. Over time, the stress begins to show in employee health, customer service quality, and staff turnover. High-potential team members may eventually choose to leave rather than remain in a system where their well-being is constantly at risk.

A Better Way: How to Set Challenging but Achievable Goals

To protect performance, morale, and long-term organizational health, leaders must learn to set goals that are bold but realistic. Below are seven practical tips to help you do just that—based on real leadership insight and frontline experience.

1. Set a Manageable Number of Goals

When teams are overloaded with too many priorities, focus becomes fragmented. Leaders should work with their teams to identify the most critical goals and reduce the total number to what can be realistically achieved within the timeframe. Fewer, more focused objectives allow teams to allocate their time and energy more effectively—and with less stress.

2. Create Realistic Timelines and Push Back When Needed

Unrealistic deadlines are often a byproduct of external pressure, poor planning, or uncertainty about the work involved. Leaders must be willing to negotiate timelines—especially when there are competing priorities. By advocating on behalf of their teams, leaders can reduce unnecessary stress and create a more sustainable pace of work.

3. Be Approachable and Open to Feedback

An approachable, non-judgmental leadership style is essential for creating psychological safety. When team members feel safe discussing their concerns, they’re more likely to speak up if a goal feels unachievable. This feedback gives leaders the chance to recalibrate before issues escalate.

4. Address Skills Gaps That May Be Holding the Team Back

Sometimes goals feel impossible not because they’re too ambitious, but because employees lack the training or experience needed to achieve them. Leaders must have a clear understanding of their team’s current capabilities and work to close skill gaps through targeted training, mentoring, or peer support. This investment strengthens the team’s confidence and ability to succeed.

5. Use Data to Scope Goals from the Start

Effective goal setting should begin with a scoping exercise. By gathering data and doing the necessary research up front, leaders and decision-makers can create goals that are based on evidence, not assumptions. This approach leads to more accurate planning, better resource alignment, and increased buy-in from the team.

6. Advocate for the Resources Your Team Needs

Many organizations assign ambitious goals without adding the people or tools required to meet them. As a leader, you likely know whether your organization is open to investing in additional resources. Regardless of past outcomes, it’s worth making the case. Asking for what your team needs shows advocacy and can prevent burnout—even if you don’t always get a “yes.”

7. Listen to the People Closest to the Work

Your team members often have the clearest understanding of whether a goal is realistic or not. Leaders should take the time to listen—without defensiveness or bias. This input provides valuable insight into operational realities and gives leaders the opportunity to make informed adjustments before performance or morale suffers.

Balancing Challenge with Support

It’s important to clarify that the point of this article isn’t to suggest that goals should always be easier. Ambitious goals have their place—especially when they help team members grow and reach new levels of performance. But there must be a balance. The best stretch goals are tough but not impossible. They should challenge the team to step outside their comfort zone without making them feel defeated before they’ve even begun.

When goals are grounded in reality, and when leaders provide trust, flexibility, and support, even difficult goals can become meaningful motivators. Employees are more likely to accept big challenges when they believe their leaders are paying attention to their needs and limits—and when failure isn’t treated as a fatal flaw.

Coaching and Mentoring as Support Systems

In high-pressure environments, coaching and mentoring can be powerful tools. These support systems help employees manage stress, develop new skills, and build confidence when facing complex goals. Leaders, too, can benefit from mentoring as they navigate the pressure of expectations from above and below.

Know When to Course Correct

Sometimes, despite all efforts, the goals simply don’t match the reality. And that’s okay. Setting unrealistic goals isn’t always a sign of failure—it’s can be a sign of learning. The ability to course correct when compelling evidence emerges is a leadership strength, not a weakness.

When decision-makers are open to feedback, willing to revise their expectations, and able to tell the difference between resistance and real barriers, they create cultures that are resilient, high-performing, and humane.

With knowledge gained from over 30 years of Fortune 500 and international consulting experience, Yvette shares her rich experience and proprietary model for changing businesses from the inside out. She is a thought leader in the areas of trust, leadership and organizational ecosystems, an award winning author and cultural consultant.

Sign up for our newsletter at www.orgsoul.com. to keep up-to-date with our new podcast episodes and blog posts (Scroll down to the newsletter sign-up section on the home page.) You can also access free resources there.

Check out the IFB Academy for courses based on our thought leadership in the areas of trust, culture, and leadership at https://organizationalsoul.learnworlds.com.