Workplace Bullying: How to Recognize, Navigate, and Neutralize Toxic Behavior at Work

No two workplace cultures are the same. Even when environments appear to share qualities like collaboration or innovation, these characteristics manifest in unique ways. I've encountered collaborative workplaces where people are eager to work together, and I've also witnessed innovative teams focused on ideation, planning, and implementation. On the other end of the spectrum, I’ve encountered dysfunctional workplace cultures where unhealthy behaviors persist unchecked due to the lack of accountability and implementation of sophisticated cover-up.

In toxic work environments, office bullies can sometimes go unnoticed or unchallenged. These individuals actively sabotage or emotionally trigger their coworkers, misusing their power to "win" in subtle or overt games designed to drive their personal agendas—but which ultimately damage the entire team and potentially the entire organization.

The Subtle and Not-So-Subtle Behaviors of Bullies

Some workplace bullies operate behind closed doors, undermining coworkers in an attempt to overshadow them. They may gossip, dismiss new ideas as invalid, or belittle others—especially because their own self-esteem is low. For them, being challenged can be threatening, so they retaliate by attempting to destroy the credibility of those they perceive as competitors.

Other bullies confuse suggestions with criticism and take offense when a teammate offers a different perspective. These are often the bullies who resist new ways of thinking because it forces them to confront their own insecurities.

Bullying as a Control Strategy

When a manager or coworker feels threatened, they may resort to tactics aimed at controlling others.

Their strategies include:

• Enforcing rigid adherence to instructions

• Stifling creative or independent thinking with insults or threats

• Withholding earned recognition or resources

• Making veiled threats or spreading rumors

  
  

In high-pressure environments, these behaviors can become extreme. In fact, some bullies go so far as to micromanage, harass, or surveil employees excessively, including sending accusatory emails, contacting them at odd hours or issuing directives.

Common Bully Tactics in the Workplace

Bullying can take many forms, including:

• Undermining contributions

• Publicly or privately insulting team members

• Upward bullying

• Sabotaging efforts or spreading misinformation

• Displaying negative body language or interrupting others

• Manipulating compensation or performance evaluations

• Issuing baseless corrective actions

• Delaying or denying deserved promotions or raises

  
  

These tactics are designed to diminish others and solidify the bully's control over the environment.

The Impact on Workplace Culture

Where bullies thrive, fear follows. Even those not directly targeted feel the tension. In cultures like this, psychological safety disappears, and team members can shift into avoidance mode—withholding ideas, avoiding collaboration, or disengaging from problem-solving altogether.

Bullied employees often feel trapped. Reporting the behavior may result in retaliation, and raising concerns to higher management might be futile—especially if the bully is favoured by leaders or if bullying is part of the organizational blind spot.

When leaders fail to address bullying or minimize the issue, the ripple effects are enormous: low morale, high turnover, damaged reputations, reduced productivity, and compromised performance. Good employees leave. Customer service suffers. Creativity stalls.

Upward Bullying: When Subordinates Target Leaders

While most discussions focus on manager-to-employee bullying, upward bullying is a real and growing issue. This occurs when employees target their supervisors or managers through:

• Undermining their authority in meetings

• Deliberately withholding information

• Gossiping or questioning decisions publicly

• Sabotaging efforts through passive resistance or cliques

  
  

In these scenarios, insecure or manipulative team members may exploit a manager’s collaborative style, framing it as weak or indecisive. When left unchecked, upward bullying can erode a manager's confidence, affect team dynamics, and jeopardize results.

What Leaders Can Do About Upward Bullying:

• Document incidents objectively and consistently

• Strengthen boundaries while remaining fair and respectful

• Engage in honest dialogue where appropriate or possible

• Seek support from HR or executive leadership

• Reinforce expectations around behavior and mutual respect

  
  

Leaders should remember that it is not ideal to give in to intimidation—it is important to create and uphold conditions for psychological safety and belonging.

The Organizational Cost of Tolerating Bullies

When workplace bullying becomes normalized, the consequences are far reaching:

• Reduced productivity and innovation

• Decline in employee engagement

• Damage to employer brand and customer relationships

• Increased legal and reputational risk

• Departure of top talent

  
  

When employees avoid interaction with bullies at all costs, they may also bend the truth or act in self-preservation mode to minimize exposure to toxic behavior. This disrupts trust and transparency across the organization.

How to Neutralize Workplace Bullies

Sometimes, entire organizations fear the "big bad wolf." From peers to HR to the C-suite, the bully may operate with impunity. However, it is possible to navigate or neutralize bullying with intentional strategies.

According to workplace culture expert Robert Sutton, here are some approaches:

• Reframe your perspective to stay grounded

• Build emotional intelligence to respond calmly and strategically

• Limit exposure where possible

• Develop an exit strategy if all attempts at resolution fail

  
  

While confronting bullying isn’t easy—especially when power dynamics are imbalanced—it’s important to assess your options with clarity and protect your long-term well-being.

In organizations where employees are expected to resolve issues with their bully boss, the power imbalance makes true resolution difficult. The person evaluating your performance should not also be your oppressor.

The Role of Leadership in Stopping Bullying

Executive intervention is critical. When bullying is reported and executives do nothing—whether due to personal loyalties, fear, or conflict avoidance—the damage intensifies. Inaction signals tolerance.

Leaders can take corrective action by:

• Offering coaching or counseling for the bully

• Reassigning roles if necessary

• Taking disciplinary or termination action in extreme cases

  
  

If you're concerned that you may be a workplace bully yourself, reflect honestly. Don't ask your team directly—they likely won't tell you the truth if they fear retaliation. Seek feedback from a neutral third party and get coaching if needed.

Navigating Bullying with Courage and Clarity

Workplace bullying is not a personality flaw—it's a systemic issue that must be addressed through cultural accountability, psychological safety, and clear leadership intervention.

If you're being bullied:

• Take stock of your options

• Document behavioural patterns

• Understand the risks of reporting in your specific context and make informed decisions

• Use internal channels or seek external support when needed

  
  

And most importantly, remember that you have a right to work in an environment built on mutual respect, belonging, and trust. Addressing workplace bullying isn't just about protecting individuals—it's about protecting the long-term health of the organization.

About the Author: With over five decades years of global consulting, thought leadership research, and Fortune 500 experience, Yvette brings deep expertise in trust, leadership, HR, culture, and organizational ecosystems. She is a multiple award-winning author and creator of a proven systems model for transforming organizations from the inside out.

Explore More: Want to lead with more trust, clarity, systems awareness, and impact? Visit www.orgsoul.com for blog updates, podcast episodes, free resources, and innovative courses for leaders, coaches, facilitators, and consultants. Visit our YouTube page for our latest releases.

Explore the IFB Academy at organizationalsoul.learnworlds.com to access powerful, research-backed courses on culture, change, and human-centered ecosystem leadership.

Want more content like this? Subscribe to our newsletter for insights on culture, leadership, communication, organizational ecosystems and organizational growth.